Testimonials

"Please read the entirety of this review. I think you will find a compelling case for why Paige Schulte is someone you should seriously consider as your realtor. In Spring 2025, we tried to sell our house in Gig Harbor using an agent with a national realty company. We thought that the “national visibility” and their website marketing techniques w..."

"Please read the entirety of this review. I think you will find a compelling case for why Paige Schulte is someone you should seriously consider as your realtor. In Spring 2025, we tried to sell our house in Gig Harbor using an agent with a national realty company. We thought that the “national visibility” and their website marketing techniques would make all the difference in contrast to a local realtor. The agent seemed capable, and she only made minor recommendations for preparing the house for sale. It was mostly moving furniture around. She also used general comps to determine the sale price of the home. Trying to sell the house during that spring and summer turned about to be very difficult (interest rates, an uncertain economy), and we had very few showings and no offers. However we found it a bit surprising that we had to be proactive in adjusting the price of the home in pursuit of a sale. We finally pulled the listing in late July, because of no interested buyers. I should also note that this agent did not live in Gig Harbor. We started the sales process again in March 2026, and this time we interviewed a couple of Gig Harbor realtors. Both seemed highly capable, but Paige was the easy choice. When we met, she’d already done her homework on the house’s size, sales history, and exactly the neighborhoods in Gig Harbor that were the competition for the home. That information was critical, and explained why we had little to no interest in the home the previous summer. It was simply priced too high when based on comps alone. Paige also recommended modest, but essential improvements that would help update and sell the house. In hindsight, she was much more astute about changes that would make a fundamental difference for a successful sale as compared to our previous realtor. We no longer lived in the home when we were preparing it for sale this year, and I was stunned at the enormous assistance that we had from Paige and her associate in prepping the home in just three weeks. Moreover, Paige monitored closely all of the feedback from potential buyers after we put the home on the market. And unlike the previous realtor, she had weekly open houses. All of this led me to realize that our previous realtor just viewed our home as just another in a portfolio of homes to sell. Her engagement was entirely passive. In contrast, Paige was actively involved in making sure that our home sold for the best price in a timely manner. In fact, there were even occasions when she referred to the home as “our house.” Now that it has sold, I appreciate more than ever all of her intuitions about the house, the Gig Harbor market, and what it takes to sell something in a challenging market. I would not hesitate for a moment to use her services (and wisdom) again if I were to buy or sell a home in Gig Harbor."

read more

— John W. | Gig Harbor -Seller

"My husband and I chose Paige after researching who was selling the most homes in Gig Harbor, and she delivered. Our waterfront property sold in a week. She staged the whole house beautifully, held open houses that people really responded to, and her marketing approach was smart, using a range of media without over-relying on any one channel. Wh..."

"My husband and I chose Paige after researching who was selling the most homes in Gig Harbor, and she delivered. Our waterfront property sold in a week. She staged the whole house beautifully, held open houses that people really responded to, and her marketing approach was smart, using a range of media without over-relying on any one channel. What really stood out was how insightful she is about what buyers are looking for. Gig Harbor is her primary market, and that depth of familiarity shows. She gave us well-timed advice on when to list and what landscaping treatment would put the property in the best position. On top of that, she came with a strong network of vetted referrals, including home inspectors and contractors, anyone you might need to get your house ready. Paige is straightforward, analytically sharp, and genuinely knowledgeable about the market. My husband and I would absolutely recommend her to anyone looking for a knowledgeable realtor in the Gig Harbor area."

read more

— Karen P. | Gig Harbor Waterfront- Seller

"We found Caitlin and Paige through a Google search for Gig Harbor real estate agents, and I’m so glad we reached out to them. As first-time buyers, we were unsure what to expect, but they made it feel easy to understand and follow. After meeting to discuss our criteria, they guided us through local home tours and made thoughtful suggestions base..."

"We found Caitlin and Paige through a Google search for Gig Harbor real estate agents, and I’m so glad we reached out to them. As first-time buyers, we were unsure what to expect, but they made it feel easy to understand and follow. After meeting to discuss our criteria, they guided us through local home tours and made thoughtful suggestions based on what mattered most to us. Things moved fast, and we found the perfect home in just a few weeks. They were always incredibly responsive, whether by email, phone, or text, and answered questions within minutes while keeping us updated every step of the way. When it was time to put in an offer, Caitlin and Paige jumped into action immediately. They guided us through the process, answered all our questions, and helped us approach it strategically. With their guidance and knowledge of the Gig Harbor market, we never felt lost or overwhelmed during the home buying process. If we’re ever in the market again in Gig Harbor, Caitlin and Paige are our first choice, and we highly recommend them to anyone wanting experienced and responsive agents."

read more

— BRETT W. | BUYER

"Caitlin was great to work with. We knew The Neighborhood Experts were the go-to team on Fox Island, and the switch from our previous realtor to Caitlin was smooth. Everything was clear and easy, and our home sold in a timeframe that made sense for the local market. She’s extremely organized, understands Fox Island real estate, and answers questi..."

"Caitlin was great to work with. We knew The Neighborhood Experts were the go-to team on Fox Island, and the switch from our previous realtor to Caitlin was smooth. Everything was clear and easy, and our home sold in a timeframe that made sense for the local market. She’s extremely organized, understands Fox Island real estate, and answers questions quickly without any runaround. You’re not getting sugar-coated answers. I always felt confident that if she didn’t know something, she’d say so and follow up with the right information. Everything was upfront, everything was organized, and she made the whole selling process easy. If we were still in Washington state, I would absolutely reach out to Caitlin again or recommend her to anyone looking for a reliable real estate agent who communicates clearly and actually follows through. "

read more

— DEANNA K. | SELLER